Buying a breast pump is not straightforward, especially with so many options out there! In this post, I will review ten of the best breast pumps, including manual and electric options.
These pumps have gained acclaim from moms all over the country based on their efficiency, ease of use, quality, increased milk production, and performance.
So, let’s find out more about the top ten breast pump picks for 2023!
At A Glance: Our Top Ten Top Breast Pump Picks for 2023 :
- Best touch-screen pump: Bellababy Double Electric Breastfeeding Pump
- Most stylish home electric pump: New Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow
- Most affordable manual pump: Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
- Cutest electric breast pump: Momcozy Double Electric Portable Breast Pump
- Best manual pump to catch let-down milk: Haakaa Manual Breast Pump and Lid
- Best portable manual pump: New Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump
- Best mid-range electric pump: Lansinoh SignaturePro Double Electric Breast Pump
- Best portable electric pump: Bellababy MiniO Electric Double Breast Pump
- Most stylish portable electric pump: Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump
- Longest battery life: SPECTRA Baby USA S1 Plus Rechargeable Electric Breast Pump
What is the Best Breast Pump?
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | |
|---|---|---|
 | Our Top Pick Bellababy Double Electric Breastfeeding Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | New Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | Momcozy Double Electric Portable Breast Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | Haakaa Manual Breast Pump and Lid
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | New Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | Lansinoh SignaturePro Double Electric Breast Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | Bellababy MiniO Electric Double Breast Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
 | SPECTRA Baby USA S1 Plus Rechargeable Electric Breast Pump
| VIEW ON AMAZON →READ REVIEWS → |
Not every mum will need to or choose to use a breast pump. However, if you do, you need to look for the best – yes, the most efficient, easy-to-use pump possible!
First off, there are two main types of breast pumps – manual and electric, each of which has its pros and cons. So, do decide which of these types of pumps is best for you!
Regardless, the best breast pumps are those that work effectively. And, of course, also pump enough milk without requiring more energy than you have to give, are quiet, and easy to clean.
So, what should you be looking out for when selecting the best pump? Below, I’ll talk about what to look for in a manual pump vs. an electric pump!
What to Look for in the Best Electric Breast Pump
There are a few important things to look for in an electric pump. The first thing I look for is a closed-system pump, though. There are two types of electric pumps – closed or open-system.
Closed system pumps have a barrier, so don’t allow milk to get sucked back into the internal pump. These types are best because, as we know, you cannot clean this interior area.
If milk gets sucked into these inaccessible parts, it can spoil, sprouting mold and bacteria. Ultimately, these contaminants can contaminate your newly pumped breast milk.
As such, you should opt for a closed-system pump. Or, at least, don’t buy a second-hand open system pump and replace yours if milk does get sucked into this area.
Here are some other important things to look for in the best breast pumps:
- Quiet noise level operation
- Discreet, small, portable control panel
- Double pump for both breasts
- Rechargeable battery
- Long battery life
- Comfortable fit
- Easy to clean parts
- Dishwasher safe parts
- Easy to assemble
What to Look for in the Best Manual Breast Pump
Manual breast pumps are a little different than electric pumps. You see, a manual pump doesn’t run on electricity; you’ll need to use your hand to pump yours, instead.
As such, they’re ideal if you’re on the go, have limited space in your bag, or just need a spare in case the power goes out. Here are a few of the top things to look for in a manual breast pump:
- Ergonomic handle
- Adequate suction
- Comfortable fit
- Durability
- Portable design
- Easy to clean parts
- Dishwasher safe parts
- Easy to assemble
1. Bellababy Double Electric Breastfeeding Pump
Features
- Double electric closed-system breast pump
- 2 x petaling massage cushion cups
- 2 x compatible baby bottles with stands, lids, and teats
- 2 x flanges and attachments
- 10 compatible milk storage bags
- 2 milk storage bag adapters
- Touch panel control unit
- USB charging
- Up to 3 hrs battery life
Things We Love!
This affordable, closed-system breast pump is one of the best breast pumps for mums with a tight budget. The set comes with all you need to start pumping, including storage bags, too!
I love that you can use the pump as a power bank, though! The pump itself has two modes with nine suction settings. So, you can find the correct suction level for your comfort!
Aside from this, it features unique petaling cups that massage as you pump, decrease pain, and increase milk production!
Pros:
- The bottles, suction cups, tubes, lids, and nozzles are made from BPA-free, food-grade PP/Silicone.
- The breast cups feature unique petaling cushions that massage, encouraging milk flow and reducing pain.
- It’s a very affordable electric pump.
- The pump has two modes (expression and let-down) and nine suction levels.
- It is a closed system pump, limiting the chances of milk or water getting into the pump.
- The pump can also get used as a power bank.
Cons:
- The set only includes one size of flanges.
- Milk tends to get trapped in the petaling cups, making it spill and the pump parts challenging to clean.
- The pump is difficult to transport, not having a bag, and the touch screen being quite sensitive.
Overall Thoughts
I think this Bellababy pump is perfect for mums who don’t want to spend too much on an electric pump! The set even comes with all the extra accessories you need to start pumping!
2. New Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow
Features
- Double electric closed-system breast pump
- 4 x PersonalFit Flex breast shields (2 sizes)
- 4 x compatible Medela bottles with caps
- 2 x flanges and attachments
- Carry purse
- Battery pack pouch
- Battery-compatible
Things We Love!
This new Medela pump is undoubtedly one of the most stylish of the bunch. It features a cute yellow-buttoned control box and comes with its own lovely Medela carry purse, too!
Aside from looks, the pump itself is very effective. I love that it has multiple settings, so you can find the perfect level for your comfort and optimal expression!
The pump itself has 2-phase expression technology, which mimics babies’ natural suckling for improved comfort and expression.
Pros:
- Ten vacuum settings to find your perfect comfort level.
- No-tangle wires make it easy to use around the house.
- It’s very easy to transport with you indoors or away from home.
- Its hospital-grade 2-Phase Expression Technology mimics babies suckling for more comfortable, natural breast milk expression.
- It is a closed system pump, limiting the chances of milk or water getting into the pump.
Cons:
- The included bottles don’t come with teats.
- The set doesn’t have a built-in rechargeable battery or include rechargeable batteries.
- A pricey pump set.
- The pump is a bit noisy.
- You need to buy batteries for the pump.
Overall Thoughts
Overall, I think that this is one of the best breast pumps for home pumping! It’s stylish, portable, cute, and comfy, offering hospital-grade pumping from the comfort of your home.
3. Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
Features
- Manual breast pump
- Easy-express handle
- 2 x compatible bottles with mOmma NaturalWave nipple, lids, and stand
- 4 x ComfortFit flanges (2 sizes)
- 2-phase expression button
- Breastmilk storage bag samples
Things We Love!
The Lansinoh manual pump is perfect to use on the go! It’s not simply a regular manual pump, though – it features 2-phase technology for improved expression!
Another of its unique features is that you can pump directly into your breast milk bag, not only the bottles, though! The set also comes with some storage bag samples to get you started.
Pros:
- You can pump directly into a breast milk bag as well as the provided bottles using this pump.
- Its two-phase technology has two modes – expression and let-down for optimal comfort and milk expression.
- It fits easily into a standard-sized handbag.
Cons:
- Some customers got tired using the pump, but that’s to be expected with a manual pump.
Overall Thoughts
According to many moms, this is one of the best manual breast pumps on the market! It comes in at an excellent price point and includes all the parts required to start pumping.
4. Momcozy Double Electric Portable Breast Pump
Features
- Double electric closed-system breast pump
- 2 x anti-overflow milk bag clips
- 2 x compatible bottles, teats, and caps
- 2 x soft silicone flanges
- Operates below 50 dB
- Small, ergonomic, discreet controller
- Rechargeable battery
- 1.5 hrs of battery life
Things We Love!
Barring all its other features, this Momcozy electric pump is undoubtedly one of the best breast pumps in terms of cuteness! The ergonomic, pink, handheld controller is perfectly portable, too.
It fits snugly in your hand like a remote control and has perfectly ergonomically placed buttons to use to control the pump. The unit also recharges, meaning it’s easy to take with on the go!
After each charge, the battery should last around 1.5 hours. The pump itself has two modes and multiple settings, too – so you can find one that’s comfortable for you.
Pros:
- It features two modes – massage and pump, with nine suction settings per mode.
- It is a closed system pump, limiting the chances of milk or water getting into the pump.
- The set is quite affordable for an electric breast pump.
- It’s completely portable as it has a rechargeable battery.
- The pump is small and discreet.
- It’s an excellent travel pump to use on the go.
- The pink packaging and design of the pump is very cute.
Cons:
- Some moms reported the pump not being as quiet as it could be.
- Its battery life is not particularly long.
Overall Thoughts
I think this is a lovely, discreet, little pump, perfect for travel, work, or home use. One of the best parts about it is that it comes in at a fraction of the price of some premium pumps!
5. Haakaa Manual Breast Pump and Lid
Features
- Manual breast pump
- 4 oz capacity
- Lid
- BPA, PVC, lead, and phthalate-free
- Made of food-grade silicone
- One-piece pump
Things We Love!
The Hakkaa is probably one of the most popular and famous manual breast pumps on the market. And, for good reason!
This innovative little pump is quite unique, featuring a one-piece body with an open mouth. Thanks to its shape, it’s so much easier to clean and use!
In fact, this little pump is a dream compared to all other manual pumps around. This new Haakaa set also comes with a lid now, so you can close it up and store your milk as needed.
Pros:
- It’s very easy to use and set up as it’s a one piece pump.
- It’s a very low-cost pump.
- The Haakaa is perfect to use to collect extra breast milk from let-downs while breastfeeding.
- It uses natural suction to extract milk.
- It’s a one piece design, without any awkward corners, so it’s really easy to clean.
- The Hakkaa stays attached to your breast by itself.
- This set comes with a sealing lid to store breast milk.
Cons:
- The set only comes with one breast pump.
Overall Thoughts
I think that the Hakkaa is undoubtedly one of the best manual breast pumps for use while breastfeeding. In fact, I would highly recommend it for mums looking to catch let-down milk.
6. New Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump
Features
- Manual breast pump
- 105° angle
- 1 x compatible 5 oz bottle, lid, and stand
- 1 x flange
- 2-phase technology
Things We Love!
This new Medela Harmony breast pump is fun and sunny, featuring a bright, energizing yellow finish. However, it’s also one of the best breast pumps in terms of features!
The pump itself has an ergonomic 2-phase handle that mimics natural suckling to improve milk expression. This particular new model has been designed with travel in mind, too, though!
It’s petite and fits in most standard-sized handbags easily thanks to its unique 105° angled flange. The flange features an oval shape, too, which also offers more comfort while pumping.
Pros:
- It’s small and compact, so it can fit in a handbag easily.
- The pump’s 2-phase technology mimics babies’ natural sucking.
- The handle is ergonomic and comfortable to use.
Cons:
- The set doesn’t come with additional storage cups and an extra bottle like the older Harmony set.
Overall Thoughts
I think this is a lovely little manual pump to take with you on the go. It’s small, low-cost, discreet, and looks good, too!
7. Lansinoh SignaturePro Double Electric Breast Pump
Features
- Double electric closed-system breast pump
- Easy Express handle
- 2 x compatible bottles, lids, teat, and cap
- 2 x flanges
- 2 modes – let-down and expression
- Portable control unit
- Battery compatible
- A/C power adapter
Things We Love!
This Lansinoh double electric breast pump is one of the most affordable, top-quality pumps out there, costing around half the price of other popular premium models.
The set is perfect for use anywhere in your home and away from home, too! Just insert some AA batteries, and you’re good to go!
The unit itself is easy to use, featuring two modes and eight suction levels. So, you can find just the right setting to fit your needs and comfort level!
Pros:
- It is a closed system pump, limiting the chances of milk or water getting into the interior pump.
- The Easy Express handle is designed to reduce fatigue while holding it and pumping.
- It’s portable, so it’s perfect to use on the go.
- It has eight suction levels for optimal comfort.
Cons:
- The unit is not rechargeable; instead, it uses 6 AA batteries.
- You will need to buy batteries for it separately.
Overall Thoughts
I think this is one of the best mid-range breast pumps available for purchase. It won’t set you back nearly as much as a Medela or Spectra pump, but it is just about as effective!
8. Bellababy MiniO Electric Double Breast Pump
Features
- Double electric closed-system breast pump
- 2 x compatible bottles with caps
- 2 x flanges
- 10 x compatible milk storage bags
- 2 x storage bag adapters
- 2 x bottle neck adapters
- 60-100 mins of charge
- Ultra-small controller
Things We Love!
The MiniO is a lovely choice for mums looking for an ultra-portable pump on a tight budget! The set not only comes in at a pleasing figure; it’s also packed with extras.
For the price, you get an extremely discreet, palm-sized pump, milk storage bags, bag adapters, bottles, bottle adapters, and more!
Of course, one of the best things about this set is its tiny controller, which can easily slip into a handbag! The pump is also rechargeable, so it’s perfect for taking with you on the road.
Pros:
- You can buy separate flanges ranging from 21mm up to 30mm.
- It’s a very affordable electric pump.
- The set comes with everything you need to get you started pumping.
- The control unit is very small, about the size of a palm, and light, too!
- It is a closed system pump, limiting the chances of milk or water getting into the pump.
Cons:
- The set doesn’t come with any teats for the bottles.
- It’s quite a noisy pump.
Overall Thoughts
I think this is undoubtedly one of the best portable electric breast pumps, and it’s amazingly affordable, too! Plus, it comes with all the extras you need to get pumping.
9. Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump
Features
- Double electric closed-system breast pump
- MyMedela app
- 4 x compatible bottles, lids, and stands
- 4 x flanges (2 sizes)
- Ergonomic, small, discreet controller
- Carry strap
- USB charge
- USB adapter
- Up to 2 hrs of battery life
- Bluetooth capable
- Carry purse
- Battery case
Things We Love!
The Medela Freestyle is one of the best portable pumps out there, featuring a sleek, ergonomic design. The main controller is small and lightweight, fitting easily into a handbag.
The pump is fully portable, with a built-in battery that can last up to 2 hrs per charge. The best part is that the unit is USB chargeable, though!
The set itself is not lacking for much, either, including compatible bottles, flanges, a USB adapter, carry bag, battery case, and more!
Pros:
- The pump connects to the MyMedela app via Bluetooth.
- The pump is easily controlled via the controller or your device using the MyMedela app, too.
- The controller weighs less than 1 lb and fits in the palm of your hand.
- It is a closed system pump, limiting the chances of milk or water getting into the pump.
Cons:
- The set doesn’t come with any nipples for the bottles.
Overall Thoughts
I think this is one of the best breast pumps for mums on the go! It fuses the finest elements of Medela’s classic electric pumps with an extremely portable design.
10. SPECTRA Baby USA S1 Plus Rechargeable Electric Breast Pump
Features
- Double electric closed-system breast pump
- Built-in nightlight
- 2 x compatible bottles with nipples and lids
- 4 x flanges (2 sizes)
- Easy-to-carry controller
- Up to 3 hrs battery charge
- A/C power adapter
- 2-phase technology – let-down and expression
Things We Love!
There are many portable electric breast pumps out there, but I think that the S1 is undoubtedly one of the best breast pumps in this category.
Not only does it have a longer-than-average battery life of 3 hours, it even has a carry handle! I love its adorable built-in nightlight, though!
This is perfect for use when traveling – no need to pack the nightlight or stress about forgetting it in the first place, either!
Pros:
- The pump has a long-lasting battery, which is great for trips away from home.
- The built-in travel light is very useful for travel, too!
- The pump has a carry handle.
- It is a closed system pump, limiting the chances of milk or water getting into the pump.
Cons:
- The control unit is a bit bigger than your average portable pump.
Overall Thoughts
If you travel for extended periods, the S1 breast pump is your best bet! The extended battery time ensures you don’t run into trouble while away from home.
Buyer’s Guide to Buying the Best Breast Pump
Buying any product, including breast pumps, whether online or offline, can be tricky these days. Which one is right for me? Will it work properly? Is it safe, efficient, durable, and good quality?
These are some of the most prevalent questions you may have when selecting a breast pump. In this buyer’s guide, I’ve included my top tips for selecting the best breast pump for you!
I’ll also go over the types, why you may need a pump, and more!
Why Do I Need a Breast Pump?
Not all moms need a breast pump. However, there are many benefits to having one around. Maybe you have to work, so you need to express milk for baby to drink when you’re not around?
Perhaps you just want to let a family member feed your baby a bottle every once in a while? Or, you want to catch excess milk from let-downs?
Or, collect milk to give baby a breast milk bath? No matter your situation, a breast pump can be indispensable.
When Can I Start Using a Breast Pump?
You can start using a breast pump at any time after your baby’s birth. However, it’s advised to wait a few weeks for a healthy, full-term baby or babies.
If your baby is preterm or unwell, you may be required to start pumping immediately after delivery, though. Just remember to consult a medical professional prior to pumping.
Types of Breast Pumps
There are a few main types of breast pumps, including manual and electric options. Please bear in mind that a pump may fall into multiple of the categories listed below.
Closed-System Electric Breast Pumps
As mentioned before, a closed system breast pump is one of your best options as far as cleanliness is concerned. These have a barrier to stop milk from getting sucked into the pump.
So, these won’t get contaminated, ensuring a clean milk supply for your baby. They’re best for busy mums who just don’t have the time or energy to pump all the time manually.
Electric pumps are also ideal for mums with low supply as they are most effective at extracting milk. Overall, closed-system pumps are best to ensure a long-term clean milk supply.
Open-System Electric Breast Pumps
Though not the best electric breast pumps, there are also open system options out there. However, these pumps don’t have a barrier to protect milk from being sucked into the pump.
Therefore, they aren’t the most hygienic, hence why they are less popular – though they will do in a pinch. If milk gets into the interior, consider replacing the pump immediately.
Double Electric Breast Pumps
A double electric breast pump has two connected pumps – one for each breast. As such, these are preferred as you can pump both breasts simultaneously, cutting pumping time in half.
Single Electric Breast Pumps
Though less common, there are also single electric breast pumps, as well as dual options that you can set to double or single-mode. Single pumps can get used on one breast at a time.
Portable Electric Breast Pumps
Portable electric breast pumps are those you can take with you away from home or move around with ease.
Whether having a built-in rechargeable battery or taking batteries, they can operate without being plugged into a power supply.
As such, they’re perfect for mums who are regularly away from home or may move around the house a lot while pumping.
Manual Breast Pumps
Manual breast pumps are by far the cheapest option compared to electric pumps. Plus, they are, by default, portable and lightweight, not requiring any power to be used.
However, this is because you will need to pump the pump yourself, likely with a handle located on the side of it. As such, these pumps are ideal for occasional use or catching let-down milk.
How to Choose the Best Breast Pump
Here are a few pointers to ensure you find and purchase the best pump for your needs.
Read Reviews
One of the most important things to do prior to purchasing a breast pump is to browse through customer reviews.
Though not all will be valid for you, or in all instances be correct, these customer reviews will inform you on typical pros and cons, as well as common product issues.
Choose Your Type
Always choose a pump that fits in with your lifestyle. Consult the section above to see which type of breast pump is best for you.
Check the Specifications
Before purchasing your breast pump, be sure to check its specifications, such as battery time, pump strength, included accessories, and other important info.
Opt for Top-Rated Pumps
You can’t always guarantee that the pump you get will be the best for you. However, choosing from top-rated options is one way to improve your chances!
Keep in Mind That You Likely Can’t Return a Pump
In most cases, a used, or sometimes unused, pump will be non-returnable. This is understandable, however, do double-check to see what the returns policy is anyway.
Check the Warranty
Another concern about breast pumps is when parts break in the future. A warranty will cover you in these circumstances. So, do check if your pump has one.
Things to Consider When Buying a Breast Pump
When buying a breast pump, there are a few important things to consider prior to purchasing.
The Pumps’ Noise Level
The best breast pumps are not only those that look good but ones that are also quiet. In fact, the quieter, the better! This is especially true if you’re using yours in public or outdoors.
The Accessories Included
A pump can be pricey, but if it comes with plenty of extras, like bottles, teats, milk storage bags, and more, then that’s value for money.
Its Suction Strength
Another less obvious feature of a breast pump is its suction strength. A pump with multiple, adjustable settings is best, though, as what is light for some moms may be painful for others.
Ease-of-Use
When putting together and breaking apart your pump to use or clean it, you don’t need any extra stress.
An effortlessly put-together pump with minimal parts will be easy to clean and operate.
Does Your Medical Aid Cover It?
In some instances, your medical aid may cover the costs of your breast pump! So, do check if yours does and what it covers before you shell out your money!
Value for Money
Price can definitely sway you when buying a pump, but do think beyond this. A pump can be cheap or expensive, but, most importantly, ask yourself, “is it good value for money?”
A quality pump that comes with all the features and extras you need is the best choice, no matter the price point.
Comfort
A comfortable pump is an essential. After all, you won’t want to feel pain and discomfort during a session, after, or before your next pumping session!
Battery Hours
If you’re buying a portable pump, do take into consideration its battery charge time, as well as the time it takes to charge and charging method.
These features are especially important if you travel and use the pump regularly away from home. A quick-charging pump with long battery life and a rechargeable battery is best.
Design
The design of a pump is important, too! So, do consider its size, weight, and shape to see if it’s a good fit for your needs!
Conclusion:
In this post, we’ve looked at the ten best breast pumps and touched on how to go about selecting the best pump for your needs. Hopefully, it helps you to find the perfect pump!